Picture of Mindy May Farmer
Mindy May Farmer
Mom of 4, librarian, writer, feminist, retro style enthusiast, bookworm, felter, and crocheter.

I Had to Lose My Religion to Find My Faith

I had to lose my religion to find my faith. I know it sounds trite. Just hear me out.

I used to believe religion made me moral. It tamed my “natural man,” inclined to selfishness, sin, and imperfection. Religion was my fixer, filling my failings with God’s ways and truths.

I Had to Lose My Religion to Find My Faith

I clung to religion because it made sense of sorrow, depression, and guilt. Religion told me the how, the why, and the why not to worry.

I felt safe, warm, and protected in religion. If I did right, chose right, and said right, I would be right, I would be all right.

Religion was not just a way of thinking, but a way of being. My religion came with its own language. I could name my sins, successes, and my purpose. I even gained a new, unspoken name.

Religion meant purpose when life felt purposeless. It made sense of the senseless. Religion gave me definition, distinction, and difference.

And, in many ways, I’m deeply grateful for the ways religion pushed me to make choices that didn’t simply focus on the now, how it helped me survive my father’s cancer treatments and death in my teens, and how it helped me find my best friend to build a life with.

But there came a time in my life when religion’s rigidity and limitations could not help me comprehend, embrace, endure, and even advocate to change the complexities, the beauty, the mysteries, the uncertainties, and the inequalities of life.

For years, I used the terms “religion” and “faith” interchangeably. If I didn’t have religion, what good was faith anyway? Where would I direct my faith? How would I know what was right? Where to go? What to do?

But my life experiences demanded I lean into complexity, love, compassion, and my own moral compass. I began to ask, “What good is an all-consuming, all-demanding religion if it can’t stand up to scrutiny?; If following your religion challenges your conscience?; If it breaks your trust with God?”

Losing my religion felt- and I know this sounds melodramatic – like experiencing a death. I mourned my religion. I mourned – I mourn – my lost self. I feared becoming all of the things my religion warned me about: sinful, prideful, offended, selfish, and worldly. Who would I be now?

I Had to Lose My Religion to Find My Faith

One day, my therapist asked me how I imagined God, separate from anything I’d been taught or told. I let my mind touch the idea and initially recoiled internally, asking, “I can do that?!” Then, I imagined Her. She radiated light, peace, hope, and acceptance. She was in me.

I started to see how faith survives outside of religion. I made lists of what God wasn’t and what God was. The first list proved much longer. It remains so.

Faith allowed me to sit with uncertainty and even embrace it at times. To allow for change. To explore. To improve and strengthen relationships. To place love over dogma. To look for God in new and unexpected places.

And, most surprisingly, faith helped me discover God in me. I saw how miracles happen through people. Medicine, science, agriculture, teaching, creating, befriending and discovering: All Godly traits. The world viewed this way suddenly seemed infinitely beautiful. I felt moved anew to hope, to help, to change, to love. If the goodness of God is in humanity, then we have so much potential for good.

I Had to Lose My Religion to Find My Faith

And that would be the reward. Here. Now. Today. Not in some afterlife, enticing us to good. Faith doesn’t follow God for future rewards or to push out sin. Faith is God acting in us and inspiring the best parts in us to help. Love and a better world now is the reward.

If we want God to move us, we need less religion and more faith. Less church and more community. Action. Hope. Perseverance. A never-ending well of love we discover and cultivate within ourselves. This kind of God makes no “us” and “them.” This God dwells with us and you can see God in someone else’s words, in art, inventions, actions. Faith doesn’t require a special book or rituals to reach God. Our conscience shows us what is good, kind, and meaningful.

I lost my religion and found my faith. Most days, I still feel a bit unanchored. But I don’t feel wrong, or bad, or sinful. I don’t see myself as the failure I feared. For a time, locked in religion, following all directions, I couldn’t keep turning to God anyway, because I felt so much anger, confusion, and hurt. Until I could begin to let those feelings go, I would always be struggling with my faith.

I’m letting God be an unknown for now. He/she/it/spirit/body/parent/being. I honesty don’t know.

But I do know love when I see it, when I feel it, and when I act on it. I know goodness. I know when my conscience feels at peace. I know when the kind of God I can follow acts through me. I have faith.

Read more posts in this blog series:

Mom of 4, librarian, writer, feminist, retro style enthusiast, bookworm, felter, and crocheter.

6 Responses

  1. Thank you so much for these thoughts. It’s given me much to think about and I’m very grateful to have this perspective to examine how I view my faith as it’s changing with time

  2. So beautiful. So resonant. Thank you for putting words to your experiences, which also happen to be very similar to mine.

  3. Love this so much. It’s fascinating to see how another person’s journey can so closely mirror my own. Thank you for writing and sharing.

  4. Thank you so much for writing and sharing this piece. I relate to your experience so much. Similar to how you described, when I decided to step away from my home religion, it was not due to a lack of faith, as I had grown up hearing it described; quite the opposite – it was a massive exercise of my faith. I also mourned – and still mourn – the death of my religion, but am growing more at peace with myself as I allow my faith – not my religion – to guide my life.

  5. Yes, Mindy! Such a thoughtful blog.
    I agree with your perspective, but am still tethered, if you will, to my religion. I still have that ‘guilt’ when I choose to miss Sunday services.
    I mostly worry that my grandchildren will have no anchor or point of reference if they never experience organized religion.
    I also LOVE a meaningful service in a “love-centered church community” to feed my soul, at times. It is tough community to find that space in small town Iowa or Minnesota, where I mostly dwell 🎶
    I am evolving daily in my faith. It is interesting 😊
    Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Our Comment Policy

  • No ads or plugs.
  • No four-letter words that wouldn’t be allowed on television.
  • No mudslinging: Stating disagreement is fine — even strong disagreement, but no personal attacks or name calling. No personal insults.
  • Try to stick with your personal experiences, ideas, and interpretations. This is not the place to question another’s personal righteousness, to call people to repentance, or to disrespectfully refute people’s personal religious beliefs.
  • No sockpuppetry. You may not post a variety of comments under different monikers.

Note: Comments that include hyperlinks will be held in the moderation queue for approval (to filter out obvious spam). Comments with email addresses may also be held in the moderation queue.

Write for Us

We want to hear your perspective! Write for Exponent II Blog by submitting a post here.

Support Mormon Feminism

Our blog content is always free, but our hosting fees are not. Please support us.

related Blog posts

In honor of Disability Employment Awareness Month, blogger Nicole Sbitani writes how it's so frustrating to see people with disabilities in the church continually framed as needing a cure or only needing to be ministered to, when in fact people with disabilities have always and will always be an important part of the community whose contributions are essential. Here are just a few of their stories - do you know any more?
I've heard the idea of "going astray" my entire church life. It wasn't until a woman said it in Relief Society, openly judging those who don't like the temple, that it hit me: taking my own path looks a lot like going astray to others.

Never miss A blog post

Sign up and be the first to be alerted when new blog posts go live!

Loading

* We will never sell your email address, and you can unsubscribe at any time (not that you’ll want to).​