Patriotic
Picture of Mindy May Farmer
Mindy May Farmer
Mom of 4, librarian, writer, feminist, retro style enthusiast, bookworm, felter, and crocheter.

Patriotic Sunday Services Ask Us to Serve Two Masters

It’s July in the United States and we’re singing patriotic songs during LDS sacrament meetings. We not only have Independence Day in the United States at the beginning of the month, but Pioneer Day at the month’s end as well. With so much patriotic potential in July, multiple Sundays can be filled with national songs. Choristers may even insist that the congregation rise to sing the national anthem.

This leaves me pondering why patriotic songs and speeches make me so uncomfortable in church services. I’m grateful for the country I live in and my family celebrates with our nation each July. But I feel unsettled and frustrated when patriotism is then intertwined with religious services.

Patriotic Sunday Services Ask Us to Serve Two Masters

I firmly believe that you can be deeply grateful for your freedoms and for the sacrifices made by many (including your own relatives), while simultaneously dissenting and acknowledging a country’s flaws. I don’t believe God or Christ has a special preference or allegiance to one nation. When I go to church services, I don’t want to divide my worship between God and nation; I don’t want to worship a nation at all.

I also believe the regular free practice of religion and spoken gratitude for that freedom is all that is necessary to show my appreciation for my religious freedom. Patriotic speeches and songs are not necessary or appropriate in church services. And no one should feel excluded from their church community because they may not feel comfortable participating in patriotic activities.

This article in Christianity Today by Kelsey Kramer McGinnis speaks so clearly and eloquently on the topic. I really appreciate the different perspectives she includes from different religious representatives. This quote stood out to me as especially powerful:

“To give a platform to both the worship of God and the celebration of America in the same service is to serve two masters, to grant power to God and the state in the sanctuary. In doing so, one makes space for the glorification of two entities that are in no way equal in the life of a Christian.

Even if leaders make a distinction during services between ‘worship’ and ‘patriotic music,’ a gathered congregation singing songs celebrating the state is ceding some highly prized religious freedom: the freedom to worship without interference and without the requirement to pay homage to government.”

Patriotic Sunday Services Ask Us to Serve Two Masters

If church communities want to hold optional, separate programs to showcase talent, appreciation, and national holidays outside of Sunday services, then they should do so. Sacrament and Sunday services should be reserved for the worship of our Heavenly Parents and Jesus Christ.

Ultimately, I don’t want to be compelled to stand or sing in church services when my convictions may guide me to kneel, or when participating may exclude those of other nations, when we should be united in faith first.

Mom of 4, librarian, writer, feminist, retro style enthusiast, bookworm, felter, and crocheter.

2 Responses

  1. I was part of a separate patriotic musical program one time that was really slanted kinda right wing. I wish I had had some input. Why not include Walt Whitman, Thoreau, Emerson? Why not an arrangement of This Land Is Your Land? Why not the story behind America the Beautiful?

  2. Completely agree. I haven’t stood or sang the National Anthem in church for years. It has caused some strife in my congregations when people have noticed me and my children sotting and not singing. However, I’ve had great conversations with those who have chosen to come talk to me about it. Ultimately, I don’t believe the national anthem will be included in the new hymn book for the reasons you’ve stated here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Our Comment Policy

  • No ads or plugs.
  • No four-letter words that wouldn’t be allowed on television.
  • No mudslinging: Stating disagreement is fine — even strong disagreement, but no personal attacks or name calling. No personal insults.
  • Try to stick with your personal experiences, ideas, and interpretations. This is not the place to question another’s personal righteousness, to call people to repentance, or to disrespectfully refute people’s personal religious beliefs.
  • No sockpuppetry. You may not post a variety of comments under different monikers.

Note: Comments that include hyperlinks will be held in the moderation queue for approval (to filter out obvious spam). Comments with email addresses may also be held in the moderation queue.

Write for Us

We want to hear your perspective! Write for Exponent II Blog by submitting a post here.

Support Mormon Feminism

Our blog content is always free, but our hosting fees are not. Please support us.

related Blog posts

Never miss A blog post

Sign up and be the first to be alerted when new blog posts go live!

Loading

* We will never sell your email address, and you can unsubscribe at any time (not that you’ll want to).​