Guest Post by NYAnn who grew up in (and later returned to) upstate New York. She graduated from BYU with a BA in English and a Master’s in Library Science, and worked in academic, public, and special libraries in Utah, Ohio and New York until her recent retirement. She loves to read and regularly posts reviews at goodreads.com. She enjoys crossword puzzles, eating, and sleeping.
Menopause . . . I knew it happened. Girls started menstruating around age 12, and women stopped around—50? 60? But it was a vague concept, rarely discussed except for jokes about hot flashes. I was grown and away from home when my mother entered menopause and heard brief reports about heavy periods, a new gynecologist and a recommendation for a hysterectomy, a second and third opinion until she was satisfied with an out-patient procedure.
I wish I had known more. I wish I had asked more questions. But would it have done any good? I wasn’t fully prepared for puberty—and that’s fairly basic and straightforward. Menopause, I learned, is totally not and differs dramatically from person to person. Would reading, listening, talking have helped? Or just set me up?
Because, at age 48, I slammed into menopause. It altered me physically. It impacted my job. It affected my interactions with others. And it dramatically changed my relationship with God.
My first symptoms were light-headedness and feeling out of it. This was odd and I couldn’t link it to anything specific. But the episodes were generally short, and I could still function. Then, Memorial Day weekend, the next symptom hit—insomnia. This was far more dramatic and severely interfered with life. I asked for a priesthood blessing. I was assured that it was temporary, and promised insight to know how to avoid similar problems in the future. I took courage, gritted my teeth, and went on.
Until I couldn’t, because it didn’t pass and I wasn’t healed, despite researching best practices in coping with sleep deprivation. After a second bout on Independence Day a doctor in our family practice prescribed a mild anti-depressant that didn’t work. I brought up the possibility of being pre-menopausal. The male doctor dismissed it; the female doctor, several weeks later, referred me to all-natural products. I didn’t realize that I could see a gynecologist without a referral (and the family practice insisted they were fully competent), so at the end of August I returned to the male who gave me an ineffective hormone. After a frightening bout with crashing fatigue in mid-September, and periods that although lighter and shorter were more frequent and accompanied by terrible cramping, I saw a new doctor who honestly admitted that she was out of her depth and sent me to a “real” person. At last . . . and I learned the valuable lessons of searching, asking, trusting my instincts, and standing up for myself. The second hormone worked! My symptoms didn’t disappear, but they were (mostly) manageable. After several years, several ultrasounds, and a diagnosis of worsening fibroids, I had a hysterectomy. That solved the cramping, but other hormonal issues continued.
One of the websites I found listed over 30 symptoms of menopause. Four I circled because they were so massive; another ten I checked off; two I added. That made sixteen—nearly half! And they were so wide-ranging and, frankly, bizarre! Aches and pains, especially in my shoulders? Gas, indigestion, and nausea? Gum soreness and excess fluid in my mouth? Over the next months and years some of these problems arrived and never left. Others popped in to say hello, waved and vanished. Still others came, eased to the point I sighed with relief, then returned with a vengeance. I soon had a gastroenterologist who, after subjecting me to tests, dietary restrictions and medications, diagnosed me with acid reflux and irritable bowel syndrome. I visited a rheumatologist who X-rayed me, sent me to physical therapy, and gave me drugs. I saw a periodontist who couldn’t find anything wrong with my gums, and an endodontist where I endured a root canal. Perhaps these additional issues would have occurred anyway—but it was hard not to think that menopause either caused or exacerbated them. Don’t ignore or dismiss health problems, even if they don’t seem related.
In many ways I was lucky. Thanks to excellent benefits through my job, everything was affordable. I had ample sick leave, and had accumulated hundreds of hours; when I eventually exhausted these I qualified for unpaid leave through FMLA (the Family and Medical Leave Act). My employer couldn’t fire me, and I retained my insurance. Even so, I felt that I was letting my co-workers down by my inconsistency. Especially at first, and then with new hires who hadn’t known me before, I wanted to send out an explanatory statement: “It’s not my fault! I’m not sluffing off! This is not who I really am!”
My husband and I didn’t always see eye to eye, and he was impatient at times with my physical woes; but having another person to talk to, drive me to endless appointments, pick up prescriptions and call me in sick, was incredibly helpful. My daughter was also kind, thoughtful and willing to assist. An empathetic but firm visiting teacher helped me overcome my tendency to downplay or apologize for my problems. I couldn’t have coped if I was alone. A support system is crucial.
I’d started journaling in college, and writing regularly had great benefits. These ranged from simply recording what was happening to pouring out my emotions and frustrations in a safe place. Pausing to organize, analyze, and reflect was more difficult, although there were occasional “Aha!” moments. Looking back at previous entries brought relief when life had improved, and sometimes “Wow!” when I realized how much I’d still managed to accomplish.
Dark chocolate is the most marvelous edible in the world and makes any day brighter (plus, it’s good for you!).
The Relief Society president (who I’d grown up with) reminded me of several sisters who’d been adversely impacted by menopause psychologically, some severely. It could always be worse. “God gives women menopause because otherwise we’d take over the world,” I declared.
But why? Why is God so indifferent? Other issues contributed to my growing religious cynicism, but menopause was definitely the start. I asked for blessings of health or comfort and tried to exercise faith and hope and do my part. I prayed endlessly, sometimes with tears streaming down my face, for help, for guidance, for some indication that a divine being was actually listening and really cared. I faithfully attended church meetings and the temple, served in callings, read the scriptures and lesson manuals and magazines, hoping to hear or see the magic words or story or explanation that would make it all right. I tied myself in knots trying to justify what I was going through and how it was benefiting me or helping me grow spiritually. I was desperate to find a “reason” that didn’t dismiss me as a beloved child of God, make light of my issues, mock me, or turn me into a worthless sinner.
These feelings weren’t incessant, or I couldn’t have survived. There were happy, productive times and periods of stability. There were fantastic, encouraging people. There were days, weeks and months when I relaxed and even laughed.
But I didn’t realize how much stress and anxiety I was imposing on myself until I decided to just stop. My church attendance had become sporadic; I went to bed on Saturdays with the best of intentions, then felt guilty when I dragged myself up late, tired, and miserable. That choice was simply, “I’m not going to try anymore. If it happens, it happens. Whatever, I won’t worry.” I turned down callings. I still studied the scriptures, but with feminist commentaries and a pen close by to mark things up. I found helpful blogs. Finally, I stopped praying. As for Heavenly Mother, I can only conclude that she’s been exiled, imprisoned, or beaten into submission. How can a mother defend this (un)Godly behavior?
Seventeen years after it began, I still suffer from digestive issues and arthritis and deal with insomnia, but the majority of female problems have ended. I’ve considerably lowered my expectations of “musts” and “shoulds,” and instead focus on what I need and want. That includes having little to do with the organized church and reading, studying and thinking on my own. I believe in the Jesus of the New Testament—especially in his healing of the woman with the “issue of blood” (Luke 8:43-48)—but object to a patriarchy uninterested in and unsupportive of women. Maybe someday they’ll adapt, or maybe someday I’ll adjust. Whatever, I’m at peace.
***
This post is part of the series Menopause and Me.
5 Responses
Oh, the insomnia. The insomnia made me feel like I was losing my mind and the fact that doctors kept offering antidepressants (all of which caused side-effects worse than the insomnia) instead of looking into physical reasons and explanations. It was maddening and only ramped up my desperation. And nothing gets you labeled “difficult” or even “drug seeking” faster than appearing unhinged in your doctor’s office.
I was lucky having seen my mother crash head-first into early menopause (this was not lucky for her) in her early 40s when fibroids and scarring from a botched hysterectomy compromised her ovaries. It was years before hormone therapy was able to completely even things out for her. So at least I had a roadmap and an empathetic mentor. I was able to get a hysterectomy (which took care of the anemia at the root of the insomnia), then spent 4 years on low-dose birth control to smooth my moods out.
I’ve found Dr. Jen Gunter’s work on menopause (The Menopause Manifesto) to be really useful and reassuring.
I’m struggling so hard with a God who designed women to crumble when childbearing is done. Our bodies are a temple, until they are no longer needed, then they self-destruct. It’s the only time I have ever really been mad at God. I don’t know how to reconcile it. I really want a gospel centered discussion about it, but none exists. There are so many things within the church that have become miserable with the onset of menopause (garments, gender-roles, lessons that “feel-good” but do nothing to actually make me feel good.) I don’t think leaving my religion is needed, but I absolutely see practices and traditions in a whole new light. Every day I wonder where I went, because I’m no longer the person I was. Do I look for her? Or do I have to find someone else to be? Becoming a new person is pretty detrimental to relationships. I don’t know how selfish to be, or how long I should tolerate things I no longer feel a part of. This isn’t a disease, it’s the way we were created. How is that possible!?!? Who would do that?
Thank you for sharing your deeply personal journey through menopause. Your candidness about the physical, emotional, and spiritual changes you experienced is enlightening and comforting. It’s important to have these conversations, as they can help others feel less alone in their experiences. Your story underscores the need for more understanding and research into women’s health issues like menopause. It’s also a powerful reminder of the importance of trusting our instincts and advocating for ourselves in healthcare situations. Your resilience and strength are truly inspiring.
I’m struggling with the same things as Heatherj and, more generally, why God made men and women with needs that seemingly clash. For example, why is it that He made most women long for monogamous commitment but most men long for sexual variety? Why did He make most women desire emotional intimacy but most men regard it with some degree of discomfort or even disdain? And if He wants sex to be part of marriage indefinitely, as indicated in 1 Cor. 7:3-5, why make so many women’s bodies incapable of doing this as soon as we hit midlife? Doesn’t that just set up a great number of couples for infidelity?
From menstruation to childbirth to now menopause, God’s design for women just seems so much more punishing than His design for men even though both Adam and Eve sinned and deserved punishment. Yet Adam’s punishment was just to work, which women have to do too, but then on top of it, we get bodies that betray us at every turn? It’s hard to believe in the goodness of God when it sometimes feels like He has it in for women!
Also, the changes of menopause really highlight how much of the behavior we assume is part of a woman’s spiritual maturity–patience, mercy, humility, generosity, etc.–is really just caused by hormonal effects on brain chemistry and vanishes when the hormones change. How are we supposed to be responsible for our changing behavior when it’s due to bodily changes that we have no control over?
I’ve never read something that helped me so much. Our journeys are aligning so significantly it’s scary. I just turned 48 and the last few months have been nearly unbearable. I feel like I’m becoming an entirely unlikable person. I sleep two hours a night. And my faith in a God that so callously tosses older women aside is wavering. I love Jesus, but you’re right it seems there is no support in the church for this Horrible stage. Thank you for sharing your struggles.