Book Review: The Gift of Giving Life

My first appointment with the midwife for my first pregnancy found me sitting in a rather shabby house in Mesa, Arizona. It had been converted into a medical office but signifiers of its uniqueness were all around–the hazy, purple, new age-y posters depicting abstract figures of mother and child, Native American relics and rugs, the strung prayer beads and buddha figurines–it was everything you would expect from a midwife’s office. The appointment was typical, my midwife checked my blood pressure, measured my stomach and then maneuvered the fetal doppler until she found my baby’s heartbeat.  As I was buttoning my pants and preparing to leave the midwife asked why I was pursuing a “non-traditional” birth? It was a question that perplexed me and I think I responded with something non-committal about not trusting the medical model of birth but that wasn’t entirely true. What I wanted, but didn’t know how to articulate, was to feel connected to other women–to feel like I was surrounded and supported by my sisters and fore-mothers as I transitioned into motherhood.

I was reminded of this scene as I read The Gift of Giving LifeDuring my first pregnancy I was desperate for birth stories–especially stories from women like me–and they were surprisingly difficult to find. My mother’s births had all been scheduled c-sections, I had no aunts present to share their experiences and the women of my ward just weren’t willing to talk about this topic. I was literally starving for information and stories about birth and all I had were the horrible shows on TLC. During that most important time in my life I echoed the question Lynn Callister asks in her lovely forward to the book: where are the mother texts? I believe that The Gift of Giving Life goes a long way to filling this huge void in our Mormon literature.

I should say, in an effort for full disclosure, that the editors of this book contacted me and asked if they could publish an essay I wrote about the birth of my first son. Upon the publishing of The Gift of Giving Life, I was then asked if I would review the book for Exponent which I am thrilled to do. So I am not, perhaps, the most objective reviewer. But despite my conflict of interest, it truly is a beautiful book. I was first struck by the cover with its subtly suggestive flower petals reminiscent of a Georgia O’Keefe painting. At 521 pages it can be an overwhelming read but the essays are well written and the birth stories are so compelling that I finished this tome within a day. I particularly liked the way this book was structured, finding it especially conducive to easy reading. The editors borrowed the structural style of Our Bodies, Ourselves in that the book is anchored by thoughtful, informative essays and then surrounded by the personal birth experiences of women.

Even though I have now birthed three children and the birthing process is no longer a mystery, I still find myself craving birth stories. Birth is an experience that many women share and it is hard not to feel connected to other women through it. What is particularly lovely about The Gift of Giving Life is that all of the stories, no matter what the circumstances surrounding the birth, acknowledge the profound nature of pregnancy, labor and delivery. The birthing process has become so normalized and controlled by the medical model of birth that it is often easy to forget what a miracle it is to walk through the valley of the shadow of death in order to escort new souls into the world. Each contribution to this work openly claims birth as the spiritual and hard work it is.

Besides the birth stories, which I always love, I want to highlight a few important contributions that The Gift of Giving Life provides. First, this is a book that openly and unapologetically acknowledges Heavenly Mother. Though there are some of the typical reasons given for Her apparent absence I appreciated that they tied this female experience to our Female Divine. I also appreciated that there was no judgement made on the different types of birth women choose. Though the majority of birth stories were of women who had chosen unmedicated births, there were stories from those who had chosen and gloried in Cesarean sections, epidurals and unassisted births. In a time where women are pitted against each other for the choices they make I applaud the editors of this book for refusing to play into this warped dynamic.

Though I loved aspects of each and every section, the one that was the most profound for me was the section on Preparation and particularly the essay by Robyn Allgood on Mother-Centered Baby Showers. This essays explains what a Blessingway is and gives some ideas on how to plan such an event for the pregnant women in our lives. I have had the opportunity to attend several Blessingways and I firmly believe that every expectant mother should be given this gift. At the end of this essay, Heather Farrell included the text of the one “mother’s blessing” we have recorded. This blessing is unspeakably beautiful and I must say, the fact that I could not be given a physical blessing like this by my sisters is of everlasting sorrow to me. For me, the approved expression of women’s power through faith, prayer and fasting is not enough.

If there is one complaint I have about The Gift of Giving Life it is that I yearned for a little more diversity. The contributors are overwhelmingly white, married and middle-class. Of course this is not unique, Exponent II also struggles with this problem. But across the birth literature there seems to be a lack of voices from women outside of the mainstream: single mothers, lesbian/transgender/queer women and those who are childless by choice. And while there were many essays that talked about infertility and/or miscarriages, there were none that did not have a happy ending.

I also want to add that generous people, including Mormons, can have differing opinions about abortion. I appreciated that The Gift of Giving Life did not shy away from this topic, in fact they included one incredibly poignant personal essay on spiritually healing after terminating an unwanted pregnancy. But I felt that when abortion was addressed in other places throughout the book there was only one opinion given and that opinion was abortion is always wrong unless it is to save the life of the mother. It would not have been impossible to find thoughtful, nuanced writings from Mormon women on the pro-choice side of this debate because those essays have already been written.

All of these voices and experiences are valid and until we start including them we cannot understand the full gambit of what it means to give life.  This is what I left The Gift of Giving Life with–there are so many stories that we women have to tell and all of those stories are absolutely vital to understanding womanhood and in extension, divine womanhood. In one of my favorite passages in the book, Rebecca Overton quotes her mother as saying “[I]t is in birth…that a woman must show her trust in  herself, her trust in God, and be consciously involved in a deliberate act of creation by giving her heart, might, mind, and strength to what is before her.” It is this act, Rebecca argues, that allows us to become “goddesses in embryo”. And while I agree that my births, and subsequent motherhood, have certainly aided in this process I also believe that becoming goddesses–becoming divine–requires so much more than this one experience that only some women get to have.

I see The Gift of Giving Life as one of the first in hopefully many texts on a variety of female experiences, texts that help us explore our innate divinity. I honor what the editors and contributors of this remarkable book have done. They have truly provided us with a mother text…and this is a beautiful gift.


If you would like to read more reviews check out the Virtual Book Tour for The Gift of Giving Life.

You can also visit The Gift of Giving Life site to sign up for their newsletter and to receive a free Meditation MP3 as well as tips to help increase spirituality in your pregnancy and birth.

There is a coupon code for 10% off a copy of The Gift of Giving Life.   Click here and after you add the book to your cart use this coupon code:  GWFWXR3F.  This code is good until Father’s Day 2012.


  1. Thanks for this honest review. I enjoyed reading your insights and I am impressed you read the whole book in a day! I too loved the section on Mother’s Blessing. I try to incorporate little things into every typical Baby shower I go to, so that all moms can have a special blessing. Even something as simple as when the mom opens someones gift, they give her a verbal wish for her or the baby. I have 2 pregnant friends right now who want a Mother’s Blessing instead of a shower and I am so excited to do that for them!

    • Thanks for commenting, Sheridan. As I reflected on why that section in particular effected me I think it is because I am almost certainly done with the stage of life where I carry and birth spirits and the Preparation section gave me a concrete way in which I can help support and celebrate another mother. I am so glad that you take time to honor your pregnant friends and help them feel their own divinity, this is so important. Thank you for helping to put this book together!

  2. I agree with your comments about the relative lack of nuance when the book discusses abortion. I don’t think it’s ever so black and white. But I did like that story that was included. I also know (since I was one of the people involved in helping solicit book stories and more minimally involved in the creation of the book) that the authors tried hard to get as much diversity–in every sense–in birth stories as they could. But at the end of the day, you have to work with what has been submitted.

    I agree that the book’s design and layout is lovely. After I bought my copy, I was delighted with how aesthetically pleasing and easy to navigate the book was. It’s diverse enough in its topics and approaches that I feel very comfortable giving it to both “mainstream” and more “crunchy” LDS friends.

    • I completely understand, Rixa. Like I said in my review, we at Exponent II also struggle in finding diverse voices to publish. And like you said, the book does strike a nice balance between “traditional” and “crunchy” mamas but I still yearn for those other voices because I love the stories of women. I hope you will continue your endeavor at the Gift of Giving Life blog and that eventually these stories will make their way to you. Thank you for your contribution to this important work, it is truly appreciated.

  3. I really appreciate the honest review as well. I admit that the topic of abortion within the LDS faith deserves more than what it was given here. It really could be its own riveting book. And diversity, good point. I would love for more texts to find their way to print that include more diversity on this topic. I would love to hear the birth stories of more LDS women throughout the world. Maybe there will be more to come. I hope this book will be a catalyst for such stories.

    I too wish every mother could be surrounded by the power of other women in a blessingway. I wish I had that opportunity for myself and maybe that is why I enjoyed writing that piece so much. I do like Sheridan’s idea because the idea has not yet caught on but I hope this book will bring more attention to it.

    Thank you for submitting your story. It is beautiful.

  4. Thanks for your review Meghan. I do look forward to all the future writings, books, and discussion this book spawns. I would have also loved to include an essay on menarche and a way to honor that transformation for young girls. (My six year old was already asking me about it yesterday.) We just didn’t have room to add it. But it’s such a great way to show sisterhood and help each other as we journey through each stage.

  5. I met the main editor tonight, as she is marrying my dear, dear friend in the morning. I kept hearing (good) whispers of her book, and when I asked my friend more about it, I was quite certain that I’d read a book review on it, and sure enough, here it is.

    Suffice it to say, I can’t wait to read it. Thank you Mraynes, for this lovely review.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Click to subscribe for new post alerts.

Click to subscribe to our magazine, in circulation since 1974.

Related Posts

Guest Post: Open Letter to Brother Wilcox

You derailed a legitimate question posed not just by young members, but by investigators like me at age 44, by recentering it on "us all" (i.e. Whites). That pivot was beyond offensive, for a great many reasons.

Decisions decisions

Sometimes (everytime?) I've had or read discussions of Celestial Polygamy the spectre of the Remarried Widower is brought up. Remarried Widower is a man...

Book Review: Your Sister in the Gospel

By Josianne Petit I learned about Jane for the first time when I was 16 and it changed the course of my life. Up until...

Visiting Teaching Message January 2015: The Attributes of Jesus Christ: Obedient Son

Guest post by Hope Click for French Translation/Traduction en français   This is Hope's first guest post at the Exponent. She is an Alaskan girl who loves...
submit guest post
Submit a Guest Blog Post
subscribe to our magazine
Subscribe to Our Magazine
Social Media Auto Publish Powered By :